Citation:

Mayer, P., K. Forshay, J. Weitzman, J. Wilhelm, Jacqueline Brooks, S. Kaushal, D. Merritts, AND R. Walter. Centuries-old land-use changes influence contemporary biogeochemical groundwater behavior in headwater streams. Biogeomon, San Juan, PR, January 07 - 11, 2024.

Impact/Purpose:

A large component of the sediment and nutrient loads that flow to the Chesapeake Bay and other estuaries on the East Coast are derived from so-called legacy sediments that fill valley bottoms throughout the Mid-Atlantic region.  These sediments filled floodplains beginning with land conversion to agriculture during the American Colonial era and the ubiquitous appearance of mill dams for hydropower.  Today, the mills are gone but the sediments remain, continually eroding and moving tons of sediment downstream carrying nitrogen and phosphorous.  EPA/ORD is part of a multidisciplinary team examining the effects and feasibility of removing legacy sediments as a stream restoration approach at an intensively studied site in Lancaster County, PA.  The complex interactions of hydrology, biology, and geochemistry create challenging conditions for study.  However, preliminary data suggest that removing legacy sediment can be effective for limiting sediment and phosphorous loads and perhaps nitrogen.  Costs of restoration may be offset by the sale of sediments as topsoil for landscaping.

Description:

Before the era of fossil fuel use, water provided power for industrial processes in the USA through a ubiquitous network of dams and mills. This infrastructure was constructed concurrently with widespread deforestation and sedimentation during the 18th through 20th centuries causing wide-spread transformation of streams and buried floodplains with so-called legacy sediments. These centuries-old changes lead to stream incision and decoupled hydrological and biogeochemical processes causing excess transport of sediments and nutrients.  In a pilot study, floodplain restoration involving legacy sediment removal was implemented at an intensively studied stream, Big Stream Run in Pennsylvania, USA. We sought to understand how restored hydrologic connection between floodplains and streams would influence biogeochemical processing of nitrogen and carbon in this landscape. Using variability in the oxygen isotope composition of catchment waters, we examined how groundwater contact times and flowpaths influenced seasonal nitrate and carbon concentrations in an 8-year, pre- and post-restoration study conducted at Big Spring Run. Denitrification potential was lowest in legacy sediments and significantly higher in the restored portion of the floodplain. Furthermore, greater nitrogen transformation occurred along more active paths of groundwater flow, especially where carbon concentrations were seasonally stable.  Our study showed that even centuries-old extreme events can affect biogeochemistry of streams and that restoration can have a positive effect on sediment and nutrient fate and transport. 

Record Details: