Skip common site navigation and headers
United States Environmental Protection Agency
Top Banner
Spacer Water and Wastewater Security Product Guide Top Banner
Bottom Banner
Spacer
Spacer
Spacer
Begin Hierarchical Links EPA Home > Water > Ground Water & Drinking Water > Water Security > Security Product Guide > Table of Contents > Exterior Intrusion - Buried Sensors End Hierarchical Links
Spacer
Basic Information
Where You Live
Primary Topics
   Mutual Aid and Assistance
   Pandemic Flu Planning for the Water Sector
   Water Security Initiative
   Water Laboratory Alliance
   Features of an Active and Effective Protective Program
   National Performance Measures
   Vulnerability Assessments
   Emergency / Incident Planning
   Security Enhancements, Research and Technology
   Legislation and Directives
   Small Systems
   Public Involvement
   Information Sharing
Water Security Resources
   Training Courses, Meetings, and Workshops
   Tools and Technical Assistance
   Grants and Funding
   Publications
   Related Links
   EPA Contacts
   Glossary
A to Z Subject Index
About Us

 

Spacer
Spacer
   

Exterior Intrusion - Buried Sensors

Detect On
Delay Off
Respond Off
 

 

Objective
Monitor asset perimeters to detect intruders.

Application
Designed to detect attempted physical access to a water/wastewater asset. Can be connected to an alarm, lights, or video surveillance cameras to alert facility personnel of attempted access.

Location Used
Buried in ground around perimeter of asset.

 
 

Description

Buried sensors are electronic devices that are designed to detect potential intruders. The sensors are buried along the perimeters of sensitive assets and are able to detect intruder activity both above- and below-ground. Some of these systems are composed of individual, stand-alone sensor units, while other sensors consist of buried cables.

There are four types of buried sensors that rely on different types of triggers. These are: pressure or seismic; magnetic field; ported coaxial cable; and fiber-optic cables. These four sensors are all covert and terrain-following, meaning they are hidden from view and follow the contour of the terrain. The four types of sensors are described in more detail below.

Pressure/Seismic
Pressure or seismic sensors are passive detectors that respond to a change or a disturbance in the soil caused by an intruder. Pressure sensors consist of a container filled with liquid, which is connected to a transducer. A seismic sensor consists of geophones that are made up of conducting coils. Pressure sensors are more sensitive to lower frequency pressure waves than are seismic sensors. Pressure or seismic types of sensors would be most useful for detecting intruders by foot.

Intruder Walking Over Buried Sensor
Buried Sensor Detection Field
Magnetic Field
Magnetic field sensors are also passive detectors that respond to a change in the local magnetic field. This change may be caused by the movement of metallic material nearby, such as movement of an intruder with a metallic weapon. Magnetic field sensors consist of series of wire loops or coils buried in the ground. These sensors can be susceptible to false alarms due to electromagnetic disturbances, such as lightning.

Ported Coaxial Cables
Ported coaxial cable sensors are active sensors that respond to nearby material with a high dielectric constant or high conductivity. Two cables-one acting as a transmitter, the other as a receiver-are run parallel to one another and are spaced approximately two meters apart. The signal leaking from one to the other creates a field between the two cables, and active disturbance of the field triggers the sensor. Materials that trigger these types of sensors can be found in people and metal vehicles.

Fiber-Optic Cables
Optical fibers are long, hair-like stands of transparent glass or plastic that use optical technology to guide light from one end of the fiber to the other. Pressure on the fiber causes a distortion in the light signal, which is detected and analyzed at the far end of the fiber. These sensors are typically woven into a mesh grid to ensure complete coverage of an area to be protected. The fibers require a burial depth of only a few centimeters to be effective. These sensors are ideal for wet environments since the non-metallic, fiber-optic cable is designed as a direct burial cable with a 20-year life expectancy.

Attributes and Features

Buried sensors are designed to follow the existing terrain and are feasible options if a site is hilly. The sensors are buried at a relatively shallow depth (ranging from a few inches to one foot, depending on the type). These types of sensors are also covert, because they are buried and potential intruders cannot see them.

These systems may be continuous or discrete. A continuous system consists of a continuous cable, such as a fiber optic or ported coaxial cable. These types of systems monitor along a continuos line corresponding to the location of the cable. Discrete sensors consist of individual sensor units that can be buried in non-linear patterns to increase the area monitored. For example, Qual-Tron sensors are designed to monitor all activity within a 30-foot radius in any direction.

A drawback to these type of systems is that they may have different sensitivities when they are buried below different media. For example, if continuous systems are buried below different types of media (such as under a lawn, then under an intersecting concrete driveway, and then back to lawn again), the sensitivities required for different types of media may be different. For example, a good sensitivity adjustment for concrete may be too sensitive for grass. Therefore, it may be best to individually zone those areas.

Another factor that must be considered when using a buried sensor is underground utilities. Underground utilities, such as gas, water, and sewer lines, must be located at a sufficient depth below the detection zone (typically three feet), so as to not cause false and nuisance alarms. Below-ground electrical wires must also be compensated for; however, the potential for nuisance alarms caused by underground power lines is not as great as with other types of utilities.

Several other factors must be considered when using a buried sensor. Rodents have been known to cause maintenance problems by gnawing on the sensor cables; this problem is limited primarily to the Western states. Installations also should not be in areas where running water will either wash away the soil that buries the sensor or cause nuisance alarms during a heavy rain. Table 1 presents the distinctions between the four types of buried sensors.

Table 1: Types of Buried Sensors

TypeDiscussion
Pressure or SeismicResponds to disturbances in the soil. Effective in detecting an intruder walking, running, jumping, or crawling on the ground.
Magnetic FieldResponds to a change in the local magnetic field caused by the movement of nearby metallic material. Effective for detecting intruders carrying weapons as small as a pocketknife.
Ported Coaxial CablesResponds to motion of a material with a high dielectric constant or high conductivity near the cables. Effective in detecting materials found in the human body and metallic vehicles.
Fiber-Optic CablesResponds to a change in the shape of the fiber that can be sensed using sophisticated sensors and computer signal processing. Effective in detecting intruders by foot.
Source: "The Design and Evaluation of Physical Protection Systems," M.L. Garcia, Butterworth Heinemann, 2001.

In order to be effective security measures, sensors must be tied into some type of alarm system or other system that alerts facility personnel when the sensors have been tripped. Many sensor systems include these features; in other cases, these features can be added on and the alert system can be networked to go off when the sensors are tripped.

Cost

Stand-alone sensors, such as pressure/seismic and magnetic field sensors, are often sold as individual components, and the cost will depend on the number of sensors required and the sophistication of the transmitting, receiving, and recording equipment. For example, a typical system will require sensor/transmitters and a receiver. In some cases, the system may need a relay if the transmitter and receiver are located at a sufficient distance from one another.

Qual-Tron Inc. provides two types of pressure/seismic or magnetic sensor systems. The first, Mini-Intrusion Detection System (MIDS) includes sensors that transmit on a single channel at a fixed frequency. This system can handle up to 32 sensors. The EMIDS system can transmit on multiple channels and frequencies, and can handle up to 999 individual sensors. Costs for these systems are provided in Table 2 below.

Table 2: Example Cost for Individual Sensor-Based Systems

ComponentMIDSEMIDS
Sensor/Transmitter$850$1,100
Hand-held Receiver$720$1,150
Relay$1,400$4,350

Both of these systems can be installed and maintained by the customer. Qual-Tron indicates that training on installation and maintenance can be accomplished in a day or less. Costs for ported coaxial cable and fiber optic cable systems are provided in Table 3 below.

Table 3: Example Costs for Buried Line Sensors

TypeCost/FtNotes
Ported Coaxial CableStand alone: $23-$46

Networked: $24-$34
Cost for hardware only. Typical installation is 300-500 ft/day.
Fiber-Optic Cables$10-$15Cost for hardware only. Costs for both 2-core (basic) and 4-core (advanced) systems
Cost information provided by Senstar-Stellar.

   Vendors

Disclaimer: The information provided in this guide does not constitute an endorsement by the Environmental Protection Agency of any non-Federal entity, its products or its services. In addition, EPA does not endorse the vendors and products listed on this site. EPA is publishing lists of vendors on this site in an effort to further public awareness of vendors identified as possible contacts for further information and possible purchase of the different types of security equipment. The Agency has selected the listed vendors on that basis. The list of vendors is not a complete list, and EPA does not endorse the products or services of these vendors.

Qual-Tron, Inc.
9409 East 55th Place South
Tulsa, Oklahoma 74145-8157
(918) 622-7052
www.qual-tron.com

Senstar-Stellar, Inc.
43184 Osgood Road
Fremont, California 94539
(510) 440 1000
www.senstarstellar.com

Fiber SenSys, Inc.
9640 SW Sunshine Court, Suite 400
Beaverton, Oregon 97005
(503) 641-8150
www.fibersensys.com

Whitaker Security, Inc.
4501 Lantern Place, Suite 100
Alexandria, Virginia 22306
(703) 768-5025
www.whitakersecurity.com

Auratek Security, Inc.
Richelieu Industrial Park
15 Buteau Street
Gatineau, Quebec J8Z 1V4 Canada
(888) 778-8440
www.auratek.net

DAQ Electronics
Piscataway Corporate Center
262B Old New Brunswick Road Piscataway, New Jersey 08854-0050
(732) 981-0050
www.daq.net/security/sabre_solutions.html

Sparton Electronics
Division Headquarters
Johnson Lake Road
DeLeon Springs, Florida 32130
(904) 985-4631
www.sparton.com


   
Spacer


Spacer Spacer

About Us | Safewater Home | Wastewater Home | Publications | Links | Contacts

Begin Site Footer

EPA Home | Privacy and Security Notice | Contact Us

Last updated on March 29, 2007 10:11 AM
URL: http://cfpub.epa.gov/safewater/watersecurity/guide/productguide.cfm